
Oh man are these boys ever polarizing. In a few short months, New York’s Vampire Weekend has become a lightning rod in the music underground. Well I wonder why. They’re from New York, they play the wealthy Columbia grad part, they also play catchy, tight, polished indie rock. Oh and they come with a mountain of hype. Sound familiar? Well first things first, let’s focus on the actual album. Of course this LP, released by XL, is basically the exact same as last year’s self recorded Blue CD-R. The songs have been polished up a little bit but the same spare recordings that delighted fans last year are essentially the same. However two new songs were added for the debut and one removed. One of the new songs,
M79, is a richly ornate chamber pop piece that adds strings and classical piano to their familiar sound and is a welcome addition. Yet the song left off, then known as Boston now known as Ladies of Cambridge b-side, was easily one of the best songs of the early recordings and its ashamed that they chose to leave it off. The rest of the album is a somewhat unique take on Afro-pop a la The Police and Paul Simon’s Graceland. Songs like
Oxford Comma and
A-Punk add a wide array of percussion, jittery guitar, and ethnic keyboards to the clinical indie rock sound. It’s amazing just how much the music stands up on repeated listens. Singer Ezra Koenig yelps about girls and kaffiyehs. His lyrics often have a subversive slant where he pokes fun at his own well-to-do upbringing. Of course all this just gives critics of the group more ammunition. Granted, bourgeois white Ivy League grads taking the styles of Indigenous African music is enough to make any liberal uneasy. Yet the band is able to pull it off so well that it just sounds like some dudes listened to some African records, added their favorite parts, and decided to have fun. Vampire Weekend have modest aims and more than surpass them. Not every band has to be Husker Du and fight the good fight. Sometimes its ok for a band to just play music that makes the listener smile and Vampire Weekend are certainly good at that.
Score: 8.3